I made a little poll because I'm curious where people stand right now.
You can also leave a comment, as long as you guys keep it civil.
The issue with leaving is.. despite the many reasons to leave.. the majority of artists is still there and the majority of new artists will join there.
I think most people would leave if the artists really did a mass exodus.
Or lower their activity there as they switch.
Me for example.. already moved out, but still a lot of artists are either only on FA, or on outside sites(making it harder to watch them outside FA).
I use this site and FA. I use this as my primary.
I'm surprised that the top result is "It would take things getting a lot worse to make me leave." I'm having a very hard time imagining how it could get worse without going back to the times of weeks' long outages.
Agreed. It bodes ominously people say that because it seems to also subconsciously say they don't really have a definition of too much. What's worse, if you do take a stand and draw the line, you're a grand asshole.
Well, guess no one said doing the right thing was easy. (Right in this case being saying no to the FA changes).
The issue with leaving is, almost all the artists are there, almost all the viewers are there, and almost all the people I talk with are already there.
I tried leaving before, years ago (over policy issues, reliability, and disappearing features), but it didn't really work out, and 20 months later I gave them a second chance. That they proceeded to flub with a month of downtime.
Even with pointing people to all my other sites, and even with all the issues that keep popping up on FA, I still get almost no interaction on any other site. Even if it's clear FA's gotten well worse than other sites that got a mass exodus...
FurAffinity has such a a dedicated (stubborn?) userbase it's almost funny. Yes, a lot of it is due to the dominant position FA has held for so long. And people like the argument that it's better to have everything in one place, usually for sentimental reasons but at other times because they don't have good business sense and let themselves get to the point that this one site is their near-exclusive place to do business. So they might suffer financial harm if they left.
I have left FA for the most part. I do still have an account and visit from time to time, but it is not my main place to go for furry art and hasn't been in quite some time. I like how other places work much better.
I voted for "I haven't decided yet", which is true at the moment. Sure, I've got adblocker, so I personally will not see the ads. What concerns me is whenever someone, who is interested in my art and wanting to see more of it, heads over to FA and doesn't have an ad blocker of some kind, and sees all kinds of mature ads around my clean, g-rated art. Even though they've mentioned that they've fixed it where only mature ads will appear if there's mature content on the page, but...it still makes me uneasy. Esepcially when some people have been posting that they still see mature ads on places that just have G-rated stuff.
The issue I'm having is that it's the one gallery that, despite not being able to draw much furry art lately, or haven't been posting much there, is that I still have the most viewers/traffic. When I used to do regular commissions, that was the place where I would get commissions from. Heck, I'd write up journals and post them to my DA and Weasyl accounts, linking back to my Commissions Journal on FA.
Then again, I also haven't been doing much in the way of commissions either. I pretty much feel like I'm a scale that doesn't really know where I lean to, but I keep teeter-toddering back and forth.
Similar to what you said above, it occurs to me that the 'inertia' answers aren't there, like:
I don't know how much these factors do come up, though. Some would be folded into other answers on the poll.
Already left since 2013's Dragoneer tantrum, banning people left and right for asking WHY. It hit a couple of friends of mine, which I couldn't stand for, plus... Honestly it was YET another mess we had to forget and move on.
I was tired of being associated with that site, with the people running them. I do NOT want to be under the wing of a bunch of elitists, special snowflakes with excuses for doing whatever unagreeable thing they could get away with
I left when there was all the ruckus about the FIRST controversial hire Dragoneer made
Especially because of the comments I received from the community. I have never seen such a supposedly loving group of people turn so quickly into the polar opposite.
At any rate, I'm probably never going back because of that
I just wish weasyl was more active in terms of comments
But so far nothing has matched what I used to get on SA
I won't lie, probably won't leave unless they do something like re-allow Cub art, or something like that. Lots of artists, and a VERY active comment regime. IT's a lot more social than other sites. I post here at FA, and I like the site, but it's not very active. other sites like Inkbunny and SoFurry will allow Cub art, so i won't go there, and I just dislike Deviant Art's organization (though I have an account).
Link
Shiuk
I don't feel there is a reason to leave, however there is no reason to not use other art sites. Loyalty to any single website or distributer hurts more than it helps. Spread your art around and get noticed everywhere. You never know where the clientele is going to come from or what clientele you are missing out on.