Sign In

Close
Forgot your password? No account yet?

About critique... by Clear-Jello

I'll be the first to admit that I do not take well to having my art critiqued. I really don't wanna hear someone else tell me something's wonky or whatever. Usually, if something's wrong with something, I probably already know and really feel shitty when it's pointed out, so please don't. I tend to argue with those who offer critique, too, so to avoid arguing with other people and making people hate me for it, it'd be best for everyone if you kept negative outlooks on my art to yourself. I know, it might be hard to resist pointing out something that looks off, but ALL art has flaws, EVERY piece of art has at least *some*thing off about it, and I really don't want mine pointed out to me 'cause, chances are, I already noticed it... and if I haven't, it's because I feel that part looks fine or I did something a certain way on purpose.

I'm sorry... I don't want this to come off sounding really catty, but I get really self-conscious and really annoyed about critique. I'll learn from my own mistakes, I don't need somebody pointing them out and adding salt to the wound, okay?

If I really want critique or advice, I usually ask the artists I look up to, the artists I'm striving to be as good as because they have the skills I want (clearly, since I look up to them). If I'm not asking you for your criticism, then chances are... I don't want your criticism. :(

And I'm especially touchy about people critiquing art that was done for somebody else. If it's artwork for me personally, it's not quite as much of an issue, but if someone's sitting there telling me how they think I should've done a commission, a gift, or a trade differently or that something looks wonky, it actually really bothers me, and I lose confidence in my ability to do artwork for other people. In fact, critique makes me lose confidence in my art period, but more-so critique on pieces for other people.

So please... just don't. If you think something doesn't look right, good for you, but please keep that to yourself because I either thought it looked fine and now feel like crap 'cause you told me otherwise, or I already noticed that it didn't look right and really don't need it reiterated for additional insult to injury. Please respect my wishes, and thank you.

(and I'm not pointing fingers at anyone specific with this because the reason this journal was written happened on DeviantArt, so don't worry, I'm not hinting at anybody here specifically)

About critique...

Clear-Jello

Journal Information

Views:
341
Comments:
2
Favorites:
1
Rating:
General

Comments

  • Link

    I suppose I can understand that. I'll keep shut up. I'm often to give critique as it was something we basically had to do in all of my college courses every time we finished stuff. But I can understand how it makes you uncomfortable, I get uncomfortable when people tell me all the things I just-so-happened to do wrong in a gift/commission when it's not their piece. ;u;
    I think it's good you made a journal about it, though, because (people like me) someone might try and offer their "help" to you and then hurt you in the process. :o

    And, especially on here, if you wanted it you can tick the box asking for critique-if someone shouts about it you have every right to ignore that.

  • Link

    I never went through art school, and that's one of the reasons why. I don't like people judging my art. I do it for myself and occasionally for a specific person, so I really don't need anyone else telling me if it looks good or not. Most of the time, I already know if it looks off, and if I didn't notice and someone points something out that I otherwise thought was fine, I get weirded out and not wanna draw. Critique has rarely ever actually helped me or improved the way I did something.

    I know about the option to request critique, and you'll more than likely neeeever see me use it. I really only want and accept critique and advice from the artists I look up to. If I wanted someone's opinion, I'd ask for it... but otherwise, I don't care to have people purposely point out flaws in my artwork and look for them explicitly.

    I know there's a difference between a lack of knowledge of how to draw something and stylization, but really, art's also a form of self-expression. Just because something looks wonky to someone else doesn't mean that wasn't intentional by artist, in fact. What if they did something strange on purpose and it's only wrong because a viewer perceived it so?

    But anyway, yeah, I don't do well with it. I don't receive critique very well. I get either very irritated or very depressed, and it will ultimately deter me from doing artwork rather than strengthen me, so I just prefer people don't do it at all unless I specifically ask for it from them in particular.