Sign In

Close
Forgot your password? No account yet?

Clean up on aisle 2 by toastysaurus (critique requested)

Clean up on aisle 2 (critique requested)

toastysaurus

UPDATED

He's the mess. Get it? hahahahahahahahaaaaaaa

Submission Information

Views:
898
Comments:
10
Favorites:
13
Rating:
General
Category:
Visual / Digital

Comments

  • Link

    Ouch. How to get this from being totally emotional?
    Nailed the sensation of isolation. A typical precursor element to suicidal tendencies. The bright light helps set him apart, though in the background, from us. I wonder if you might try making the peripheral shelves, closest to us head more to black. I wonder if you could balance most of the foreground going to black right and left without loosing his location. Thinking a soft focus phenomenon, the dirty halo of all the shit we're paying attention to and missing him among.
    Perhaps loose the text on the 'hoops' box? Put text elsewhere so there are fewer elements around him pulling eyes and some other elements making the eye move around the room, unable to find anything as clear and defined as him.
    Not sure if Tears are even needed. The sad face is a perfect sell in my mind. Tears, especially comical tears may push past the 'sale' of choking loneliness. I think that, if outwardly, he was behaving normal, completely innocuous but torn up inside, it would intensify the phenomenon.
    Would putting figures in the foreground help increase the sense of isolation? Perhaps bodies passing in front of him such that we get a glimpse of a figure crying out for help amid a sea of faces who don't care? Might needlessly complicate the foreground.

    • Link

      Ah very helpful critique!

      The picture didn't start off as being this emotional, I had already added the text before I really realized where I was going with it. But yeah I can see how its a bit distracting now.

      The tears for sorta thrown in and even after submitting this, the more and more I saw it the more it bothered me.

      As for people in the foreground, I did contemplate it but then the setting is suppose to be him leaving the store after closing, sorta reflecting on that job is all he has.

      I do wanna edit this now though!

    • Link

      thank you so much!

      • Link

        No proballo. Also, now that I look at what I said:
        I had meant that I wanted to keep -my- critique from being full emotion. I am feeling the hell out of this image because it's playing upon the right strings. Can't wait to see what you change and how it impacts!

  • Link

    I'D SWEEP HIM UP INTO MY ARMS
    For real this series is real lovely. Nailing that "I'm so tired of everything where do I officially give up?" feel.
    I wanna hug him. ; ^ ;

    • Link

      Yeah I think its helping me really prepare for the comic.. though even might turn it into a picture series instead.

  • Link

    That feels much smarter! These are hard to pull off...

    • Link

      Thanks lol! Your critique really helped~