appropriate response.

Neither holy toller nor hipster he be. So far so good on the first date.

Quick Bit of Critique, It's not visually conveyed that the second question is a follow-up to the last. Panel Two, Sara's face is relaxed and listening, but panel three it's more stern and concerned. I'd say the expression in panel two should leer more to what's shown in panel three, if it's just like her eyes narrowed slightly more, eyebrows raised.

low hanging fruit

I'm told that the key factor in a successful relationship isn't the presence of traits that you love about each other, but the absence of traits that you can't stand. If that's true Sara's on the right tack.

Minor crit: it's 'atheist', not 'athiest'. (More athy than any of us!)

I used to have a fedora, it was part of a costume.

I wore that, sunglasses, and a t-shirt that read "IRS AUDIT AGENT."

Before you think I'm clever, it was in a Foxtrot cartoon.

Foxtrot is the Dreamcast of Sunday Funnies. Superior to the others of its generation, largely ignored and forgotten, and it appeared and disappeared before anyone noticed.