This is the most recent variation on the Pikachu MLP plush toy. On this iteration, I turned up the pony-to-pikachu ratio and tried to tone down the yellow with a brown mane and tail. I'm still not totally satisfied with it, but I feel like it's better than the last rendition.
Yay progress!
Link
keirajo
Maybe you could try to do Pikachu eyes for it, which are just brown circles with a highlight sparkle? Or black...depending on the rendition of Pikachu (game or anime). :)
I do like the multi-color in the mane and tail though, it makes it more unique! :D